fbpx

sig p220 vs 1911 recoil

    sig p220 vs 1911 recoil

    Thus it was that the cops and the shooting public were delighted to discover that the SIG P220, which like the lightweight Commander had an aluminum frame, wasnt anywhere near as difficult to shoot as the alloy-framed Colt. Sig borrowed the inferior mainspring position which resulted in the mainspring being positioned outside the back strap and covered only by the flimsy plasticky grips. There is no comparison between the two in terms of format and function. From the world leader in firearms . But as a fun gun its a blast. Travis is a former Marine Machine gunner who served with 2nd Bn 2nd Marines for 5 years. The gun lacks manual safety. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! and been wanting it for several years but always out of stock. Although the original flimsy stamped sheet metal slide has long since been obsolete the present guns not only suffer from past design problems but now have new ones as well. There, I said it. However, in the wide world of guns, its universal that you do indeed get what you pay for. The pistol was also used in police enforcement and military duties in Denmark and Japan. Recoil Spring: braided and factory standard @ 16 lbs . I know the 1911 is Gods Gun (though I bet when I get to the Pearly Gates, Saint Peter will be rocking a Sig) and the physical manifestation of America! in forged steel. The distance the trigger had to move forward to re-set the sear was just enough to give a buffer against unintentional discharges under stress, but not so great that it appreciably slowed down the shooters rate of fire. The author has seen duty belts weighing in the 15- to 20-pound range once festooned with multiple handcuffs, a full-sized baton, heavy flashlight, portable radio, and ammunition. It is about the same weight as the six-shot Smith & Wesson Model 10 or Model 64 Military & Police revolver with a 2-inch barrel. Required fields are marked *. In stainless, the full-size P220 is a fairly massive handgun, and feels far bigger and chunkier that the 1911. Firing from a single- or double-action trigger pull, this pistol is built with a 4.4 inch barrel set in a stainless steel slide topped with windage-adjustable iron sights. It handles great and the lightweight slide makes . It takes a real effort to avoid placing my thumb on the slide lock, and often once the shooting starts and pressure builds, my thumb goes tight to the grip and rests on the slide lock. Save. Sig P220-P229-SP 2022-Sig 1911-M400. The Sig P220 and the 1911 are both single stack, all metal defensive guns that have a long track reco. The P220 uses an enlargement of the chamber locks onto the ejection port of the slide. This allows the shooter to clear the chamber without needing to disengage the safety. Please dont give me that look, as if Ive lost my head. I also have a P220 SAO Elite 10mm and a P220 SAO Legion in 10mm. FYI, with heavy loads the SigP220 is the more comfortable pistol to shoot, much more comfortable grips and ergomatics! While known more for their revolvers and M&P pistols, S&W should not be overlooked when it comes to 1911s. Remove the slide, and you can then remove the barrel and recoil spring. I also have the sig 1911 fastback nightmare. I will champion the following statement till the day I die: Anything the 1911 can do, the Sig Sauer P220 can do better. This first reason a Sig P220 is better than a 1911 is a no-brainer. Best 9mm Ammo in 2021 [Self-Defense & Target], 6.5 Creedmoor vs .243 Win Cartridge Comparison, Viridian Laser Sight AR and Pistol: Review, Marlin 1895 .45/70 Hands-On Review The Guide Gun, [Review] Ruger LCP II: The .22 Pocket Rocket, Features a low profile and higher grip for better control, Some reviews say that the frame and slides may get sloppy after lots of heavy use, but it can be remedied by adding lube, Most models only have an eight-round capacity. In DAO, the points made about staging the pull reliably and at the same release point in the article referring to SIGs common DA/SA trigger, is spot on and reminds me of the same sense of control I notice in my S&W 340PD revolver. I have a three of Sig P220s to include a Dark Elite. Its a locked-breech, short recoil-operated pistol that utilized SIGs own system. As a modern combat handgun its lacking. Magazines Magazines. This is because of the huge availability of Chinese imports and knock-offs online. Simple OperationSome might argue that a 1911 is as simple as it gets, with one trigger pull to master. A forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer Pistols and SIG Sauer Rifles owners and enthusiasts. Sources: Monkey Wrench, Sig Sauer, Colt, Drew Perez, Only one company builds Sig P220s (but, TJ is the man that can customize to your needs). Bugs me too! Recoil Spring Set - 1911 Carry .45ACP . SIG did it right here. Taking the gun apart is very easy, and SIG makes it simple. I later hit the 1-inch mark at 25 yards with a 5-inch SAO P220 and inexpensive MagTech 230 grain FMJ. Factory replacement recoil spring guide rod for SIG GSR 1911 models. (Though, oddly enough, 9mm, 10mm, .38 Super and .22LR are other available calibers for both pistols). However, for new gun owners or people who switch up their carry pistols, this can get confusing and possibly unsafe very quickly. Hes trained with the Romanian Army, the Spanish Marines, the Emirate Marines and the Afghan National Army. The SIG Sauer P220 is an alloy-framed, semi-automatic pistol that operates on the classic Browning style tilting-barrel short recoil action. It is what it is. Have never found ANY other pistol capable of doing that, reliably, all the time. The P220, which is also available with an E2 grip, is significantly more slender and maneuverable. If you dont wanna carry the real thing that actually works as its supposed tom dont carry a gun. BONUS OFFER: Get your free shooting range targets to print at home! First is Colt 1911 Government 45 ACP in blued finish, 5" bbl, two mags, blue case manual lock everything that it came with. All SIG pistols and products are fine weapons, but this one is particularly impressive. Check and mate. This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. The magazine latch is very poorly designed and great care must be taken if you decide to remove it as its hair pin flimsy spring (which is way less durable anyway as compared to the rugged Colt/Browning coil spring) is not encapsulated and will fly off into the stratosphere when removed never to be seen again. . Come join the discussion about Sig Sauer pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Now lets face facts no company these days uses quality parts unless they absolutely have to and Sig would have never dropped the econo-grade stamped slide because they wanted too. With the success of the P220, SIG Sauer has cemented its position as a leading pistol manufacturer in the civilian market. Who sells it? Find out more here. I bought the 1911 before I bought the Sigs. They are manufactured with proper materials, hardened and stress-relieved to withstand a lifetime of hard use. Colt 1911 VS SIG Sauer P220. That is the best way to compare it to feeling the P220. Compared to the P210, the P220 is a far superior firearm in terms of performance and aesthetics. With a 4.41-inch barrel, the SIG was a little longer in that dimension than the 4.25-inch Colt Commander, but more than half an inch shorter than the 5-inch Government Model. With an overall length of 8.3 inches and a weight of thirty-two ounces, the XD (M) is a surprisingly light and comfortable pistol. Hi! Join 212,000 avid gun enthusiasts and claim your print-at-home shooting drills. This is, of course, exactly what you'd expect from one of the world's finest firearms manufacturers. If this pin snaps off or becomes loose it will fall down into the guns mechanism hopelessly jamming the gun up tight, just what you need in a gun fight to the death. DA/SA Full-Sized Pistol Chambered in 45 ACP . Also worth noting: my experiences with Sigs customer service team have been nothing short of exceptional. The original hammer/trigger system was made not of high grade bar stock or forged parts but of a cheesy powdered compressed metal (sintered) later to be replaced presently with and even worse set of parts, the disastrously inferior MIM cast parts guaranteed to go snap, crackle and pop at the most inopportune times. Oddly enough I paid less than half for it than I did the Dan Wesson and it might have been a touch cheaper than the P220. "Nothing is easier than the expenditure of public money. I may head to the range this weekend and rent a 1911. (I know, the heresy! Smith & Wesson SW1911SC E-Series. The . 5 Best .45 ACP Pistols, Sig Sauer P220: The Sig Sauer P220 Combat is a pistol with a super-light aluminum frame, which is quite different from other .45 ACPs and is very customizable. Sig P220, 224, 226, M400 TREAD, 516 G2 Patrol SBR, 716i TREAD, MPX K, 1911 Emperor Scorpion Fastback, 1911 TACOPS Carry, 1911 Ultra Carry. Sport Type: Hunting. Just letting you know.Yes, overall rating the Sig P220 wins the minds of most shooters. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! However, they paid the price of a caliber that offered minimum acceptable power, especially when the ammunition was fired from a short barrel. In conclusion a Colt/Browning this gun certainly is not and never can come close to being ever. Other than a small change in grip diameter and different mags the similarities are very welcome and useful. IE the P220 will cycle with Magtec, American Eagle ect just as well as it does with Sig, Fiocchi, Buffalo bore and ever old Norma. This is a base model when compared to other SIG P220s. The P220 Carry is a shortened version of the full-size P220. 8 minute read. This means its short, and very well designed. Then I can finish the trigger pull to ensure a very well placed shot. For a while, it came to the United States as a Browning BDA model. For those unfamiliar with the P220, it is the handgun the company's current stable of pistols owe their heritage to. In free states, the eight rounds of .45 ACP severely lacks when compared to the 21 rounds I can get in a CZ P09, or even the 13 rounds I can get in a Glock 21. The lightweight Commander was dubbed by one of its greatest advocates, Col. Jeff Cooper, as a gun designed to be carried much and shot seldom. Most who had fired it considered it much more unpleasant to shoot than its big brother, the full-sized, all-steel Government Model. The P220 10mm Legion has a gray finish that resembles Parkerizing. March 30, 2021. Reliability is top notch. Please consider creating a new thread. ), HK (Nice!)) Youtube has de-funded most gun content. This is a constant problem for me. You have entered an incorrect email address! The gun was and is extremely reliable. Funny how that works when only one manufacturer makes a gun. I would have whole-heartedly said 1911..UNTIL I shot my first p220. Mason's Rifle Room. Gun deals, hand's on reviews, educational content and news on law changes, every day! Both are awesome handguns. The Marlin 1985 is an upscale, heavy-duty version of their excellent 336 lever rifle. Has a higher bore axis, parts and mags are expensive. Come join the discussion about Sig Sauer pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! I had already read it and that is where my question originated since the Sig p220 is a John Browning design same as the M1911a1.The following paragraph illustrates this fact. The Rifle section is dedicated to James Henry Mason, aka forum member "horse"; shooter, collector and rifle authority, who left us too soon. Only when a custom gunsmith (or, beginning in the 1990s, the manufacturers) put a beavertail grip safety on the lightweight 1911 did it become as comfortable to shoot as a P220, and allow the shooter to take advantage of the reduced muzzle jump potential afforded by its lower bore axis. With the 229 you change calibers by changing barrels (and maybe mags). The P220 weighs a tad less than a lightweight Commander, 25.7 ounces unloaded. However, unlike a traditional 1911 (or even a SIG Sauer X-Five SAO), the Legion SAO's thumb safety does not lock the slide. The short recoil 9mm, 4 5/8" barrel, along with the slide, allow for quick second shot resets, getting the shooter on target faster. In fact, any 1911 that would be generally be considered to have the correct accepted upgrades to be a modern fighting pistol is so vastly removed from the original 1911A1 design that it could be considered a new design. There are extended mags for the P220 which makes the step up largely unnecessary. The magazine release only requires a very slight movement of your hand to accentuate. The P220 always fit most hands well. I have been shooting 40 for years and looking for something else now. There's nothing wrong with the original P220; it's a perfectly solid gunbut the Legion is better. $19.95. You think all those guns, with sell prices ranging from $499 to over $2,000, all have the same level of quality standards? The Swiss Army needed a new pistol to take the position of the SIG P210. Made to the same high standards as the parts already found in your Sig Sauer firearm. Like. SigTalk is a forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer enthusiasts. The duty belt carries a great deal of equipment. It comes down to whats more important for you, reliability/accuracy/ergonomics, or capacity/size? Grips, sights, trigger kits etc. No jams. I don't think you can talk about "how 1911s handle 10mm" across the board, as though they are all the same gun. Yet, there are still debates among the hard core users. This particular model is interesting model due to the fact it was made when Germany was split into West and East Germany. For generations, officers carried little 2-inch .38 caliber revolvers as off-duty guns, simply for their light weight and convenience. The use of a single stack does make it a bit dated compared to modern handguns, but SIG has introduced a double-stack .45 ACP called the P227 if you want a few more rounds. I just wish Id thought to get a matched pair when they were in production. Here in good old SAfrica I rely on my old SIG P220 over anything else yes, the magazine does not hold too many bullets, but who cares, you a) wont miss you first (most important) shots (OK, first may go bit off due to the double action but second shot is dead on) &b) it wont jam. It is popular with civilian shooters in competitive events such as USPSA, IDPA, International Practical Shooting Confederation, and bullseye shooting. Get it while you can. Which is better, the 1911 or the Sig P220? It doesn't appear to belong to anyone. Several Gun Writers have stated the U.S. Military rejected the Sig P226 precisely because of its weak stamped sheet metal slide which as stated was replaced with the more expensive bar stock slide. Customizable * * * *. Given the size of the P227's grip makes it hard to recommend over other double-stack .45s like the HK45, HK USP, CZ 97, SAR K2-45, or even striker-fired guns like . Many double-action semiautomatics had a DA trigger pull that was heavy, rough, or downright lousy. Designed in 1975 by the SIG Arms AG division of Schweizerische Industrie Gesellschaft (now SIG Holding AG), and produced by J. P. Sauer & Sohn, in Eckernfrde; it is currently manufactured by both SIG Sauer companies: SIG Sauer GMBH, of Eckernfrde, Germany; and SIG Sauer, Inc., of New Hampshire, United States. Maybe you handled a norinco rip-off, but the P220 is a dream and 100% opposite of your tedious description. We dont call Canada California, just because they both start with Ca. I love both my Sig Tacops 1911 and my P220 Carry Elite. They all worked just fine afterwards. It's a heavy beast best described as a boat anchor. ), load them in the magazine, and then feed them through the pistol, one after another. If you only use 1911s for all your pistol needs, I can see this being acceptable, maybe even preferable. If you were in a situation where you knew people would be shooting back at you, and you could only choose between a Sig P220 or a 1911, both loaded with modern hollow point defense ammo, which would you grab? Capacity and a large size mean squat, reliability and accuracy are king once youve found a pistol that fits your hand. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. He it is that shall come out of Jacob to rule, who has been set by the Father as king over Sion, his holy mount, and shall have the Gentiles for his inheritance, and the utmost parts of the earth for his possession. Youtube has de-funded most gun content. Interestingly enough in the United States, the P220 is mostly known for being a .45 ACP handgun. Kimber Aegis Elite Custom (sold); 9mm Springfield Loaded Stainless (sold); Kimber Stainless Custom II (sold); Dan Wesson Valor; Les Baer Custom Carry (sold); Wilson Combat X Tac; Guncrafter Industries No Name (sold); Springfield 1911-A1 "Custom . However, the P220 has been chambered in 9mm (9mm vs 10mm), .45 ACP (10mm vs .45 ACP), .38 Super, 10mm, 9mm Steyr, 7.6521 Parabellum, and there is even a .22 LR model. A Colt all steel Delta Elite would be hard to beat. The SIG Sauer P220 is one heck of a gun. The nice thing is since you have a 226 things will be the same. Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. They are very similar and also very different. If you've kept your P220 or P226 box stock without tweaks or upgrades, this is the correct replacement recoil spring because it provides the factory-spec 20 lbs. Now, the P220 .45 gives the plainclothes officer a much more attractive option. If you live in a state that has magazine restrictions the SIG P220s low capacity may be a perfect choice for a home defense gun. SHORT RESET TRIGGER KIT SIG SAUER P220. Your thoughts? Next time I will verify what I wrote before posting it. Sig P220 45 Dark sig finish, 4.3" bbl . Later offered as the steel-framed Combat Commander, the Colt put on an additional 10 ounces in that format. NO JAMS. Controls shot, right side. As a matter of fact there is one roll pin in the top of the frame that has its rear end hanging out in thin air and is pressed down on by a very strong spring. The Glock carries thirteen rounds in its double-stack magazine, while the P220 loads eight cartridges stacked up like spoons. The foot of the barrel on a 1911 is not as robust as that of the P220, due to its size and split design for the link. The single action trigger has a slight bit of take up, but you meet the wall quickly. - Color coded 14, 16, 18 and 20 lbs recoil springs for optimal tuning of recoil impulse with various types of ammunution. I will champion the following statement till the day I die: Anything the 1911 can do, the Sig Sauer P220 can do better. I think that the Sig P 220 is an evolutionary development from the 1911. The double action trigger is heavier and longer, but still very smooth and very compliant to trigger pull. Recoil Pads & Cheek Risers; Other Parts; Accessories Accessories. 1; 2; Next. I like them both very much but I also have a P226 stainless and if I were transitioning to .45 caliber I'd first go with the P220 then later chose the 1911 as your next platform. Just in case it doesnt, yknow, work all the time. The SIG P220 Carry is an obvious commitment to handgun manufacture as there are many different versions of this handgun. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. SigTalk is a forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer enthusiasts. Since the heading question was about .45 ACP, I limited it to that. The E2 grip is a good improvement. Suffice it to say, the comments from bhp0 is just not true. By R.K. Campbell. If I had to pick only one 10mm it would be a P220. Sig P220, 224, 226, M400 TREAD, 516 G2 Patrol SBR, 716i TREAD, MPX K, 1911 Emperor Scorpion Fastback, 1911 TACOPS Carry, 1911 . (Photo by Michael Anschuetz) On March 29, 1911, the U.S. armed forces officially adopted a pistol designed by John Moses Browning. Right off the bat most gun advocates in the shooting crowd that are not die-hard 1911 users have recognize the Sig P220 taking the lead on this. The P220 felt superb, was stunningly accurate, andget THISI didnt have to do anything to it. Because it was reverse engineered it also could not function with sharp shouldered lead bullets like the super accurate Keith 200 grain semi-was cutter. I have no problem with the 1911 in 45 but would not do one again in 10mm. Said system and the P220s descendants are widely used throughout the worlds militaries, including Federal Law Enforcement and elite units like the US Navy SEALs. Therefore, the P220 was created. Thanks for the input so far. I am wondering if I should go with a quality 1911 or the sig p220 and stick with the same design as my p226? Polymer Derangement Syndrome is a Crazy Mental Disorder. My friend Chuck Taylor is one of the leading authorities on combat handguns and the author of a great many articles and multiple books on the topic. The P220 is a popular gun, and its hard to point out standout features for just this model when so many different models exist. Massad Ayoob confesses that the SIG P220 is his very favorite SIG pistol, and indeed, one of his all-time favorite handguns. 4. Ive had both, for me, the sig is hands down the best platform foe ten mil. Pull the slide rearward until the half moon cut out of the slide is above the takedown lever. The SIG P220 in its Combat variation is designed for service and protection. A base model 1911 often rubs me the wrong way, but the P220 is a soft shooting, easy recoiling gun. The P220 set the standard for decockers and positions it for easy thumb reach. With origins dating back to the late 1970s, the P220 is considered by many to be the one that started it all for SIG SAUER. The SIG P220 is a fascinating firearm from an intriguing era. Subsequent shots are single action, giving you a light and short trigger pull until the gun is decocked. I used to be all about the G20/40 until I got my 10mm P220. Internally, Sig's new compact cannondubbed the "P245"shared little with the P220. The new P320-XTen comes standard with SIG's excellent XRay 3 day/night sights and an optics cut. If you have a tight budget but want a high-quality pistol, you can get these guns for around 400 bucks. Its easy to reach, and the thumb can quickly drive it downwards. Probably not. As a hammer-fired gun, a nice beavertail means you dont have to worry about hammer or slide bite with these guns. 3. Sig Sauer P226 Legion Full-Size 9Mm 4.4In 3X15Rd. Did you hear that? My local dealer has a P220 Legion SAO that I will probably be bringing home. Both the above problems stemmed from the fact that the empty case being ejected was actually pushing down on the top loaded round in the magazine and the rim of the ejected round would often catch on the mouth of the round waiting to be loaded or in the case of the lead bullet actually plow a groove through the shoulder and then peel back the case mouth like a banana resulting in a catastrophic jam with the loaded round on its way into the chamber. Get gun deals, hand's on reviews, educational content and updates on law changes daily! Get gun deals, hand's on reviews, educational content and updates on law changes, daily! Done. Yell at me all you want, I know I'm right after years of using both platforms -- and here's my justification. In a fall or sudden impact the grips can shatter or crack and then the mainspring strut can become bent or even snapped in two putting the gun out of action. Price is certainly a factor, as is the caliber, both of which may not appeal to some. Fire Control Unit is the term used by Sig to describe the bundle of parts the ATF considers the firearm. Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. As a retired officer of the Swiss Air Force it annoys me. SIG is known for its quality handguns, and this one is no different. My Compact was a bit odd-feeling from the way SIG chopped the frame. (not CA). With what's going on in the world these days I'd say get the 220. The SIG P220 is one of the flagship guns of the SIG Sauer handgun lines. I already have a P220 SAO Carry two tone, P220 SAO two tone, P220 SAO Dark Elite, P220 SAO Legion, P220 SAO Match and a P220 SAO Super Match. Designed by John Browning, the M1911 is the best-known of his designs to use the short recoil principle in its basic design. Along with those I have four other 45acp 1911s. Some of us prefer the cocked and locked Model 1911 chambered in .45 ACP for carry. Mfg: Viridian Weapon Technologies. 1 - 20 of 31 Posts. There are no points of pain when firing round after round. This gun is remarkably simple. The full-length slide rails are on the inside of the frame, which lets the slide sit deeper, lowering the bore axis to reduce felt recoil and muzzle flip. The 220 carry is just a .45. Conclusion: Is the SIG Sauer P220 a Good Gun? Learn how your comment data is processed. When you buy a P220, you know youre getting a quality gun. A prolific author, Ayoob is the author of Gun Digest Book of Concealed Carry, Gun Digest Book of SIG-Sauer, Gun Digest Book of Combat Handgunnery, Massad Ayoob's Greatest Handguns of the World and many other books and more than one thousand articles on firearms, combat techniques, self-defense, and legal issues. "A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government", You really need to consider that the 1911.

    Joey Pants Fired Wmmq, Kristin Pitzen Tiktok, Morriston Crematorium List Of Funerals Today, Clearwater Mn Police Reports, Articles S

    Abrir chat
    😀 ¿Podemos Ayudarte?
    Hola! 👋